27 Comments
User's avatar
Mr.M's avatar

Best starting lineup this team has is Claxton (when he returns), Smith, Wilson, Powell, then start Giddy (so he doesn’t lose what little trade value he has) sub in Jones when necessary.

Piccolomair's avatar

I've already started thinking trades....you think the Hawks would swap Dyson for Giddey. Feel like the hawks can use someone to better set up their players while the bulls could better use a point of attack defender.

The fact that we all know the Hawks would tell us to fuck off probably speaks volumes to the actual value of giddey

ExpiredTradeException's avatar

Dyson Daniels is good, no? So, no.

your friendly BullsBlogger's avatar

I don't think there's a point now to even speculate on Giddey trades, BUT also I simply like speculating on trades.

Phoenix is always doing dumb shit, and they supposedly feel they need a point guard. The only deal that works with cap rules now is Miles Bridges, which isn't 'positive value' for Giddey but is at least an expiring contract and the Bulls can cut ASAP (for morality reasons if anything). Now, Phoenix just used a pick to get Bridges in, but like I said they're doing dumb shit all the time. And for the Bulls this could be 'selling low' as you're just getting out of the Giddey contract, but as we saw with Pat the value CAN go lower.

your friendly BullsBlogger's avatar

another 'I dunno, they're dumb' team is the Pelicans. a Giddey-for-Poole swap also would save them money and get them well below luxury tax.

And like the Bridges idea, Poole is expiring, could be more useful at the deadline to re-aggregate

your friendly BullsBlogger's avatar

yet another is our old friends The Kings. Deandre Hunter makes nearly identical money and is expiring. Kings could reason (they're dumb!) that they are getting younger cost controlled talent

H_Vaughn's avatar

Giddey for Suggs? Helps Orlando lessen their tax burden by $7M. Would appear to give them some distribution help and slightly more impact offensively. It's not a fair trade, though, as Suggs is genuinely impactful defensively, if somewhat overpaid.

Captain Kirk's Tooth Gap's avatar

I know it's already been mentioned by others, but I think the Bulls should sit Giddey for however long it takes him to "recover" from whatever mystery wrist injury he has. This allows Giddey to get his head on straight while also keeping him from tanking his value too much.

It also has the benefit of putting Jones in with the starters, which I believe will help them in multiple ways as yfBB points out in this article. Then let Swain and Sellers play backup point guard and see what they have. I expect them both to start out pretty terribly but we don't really care about losses right now. Might as well let them get playing time and see if there's anything there worth investing in.

Best case scenario Giddey comes back like 15 games before the trade deadline and goes out and puts up empty triple doubles which raises his stock enough for the Bulls to move off of him without having to give up anything of value.

Piccolomair's avatar

I don't think the "injury" is that big of a deal and plus we don't have any other ball handler on this team after Tre. Swain isn't ready, sellers or Powell aren't point guards.

Captain Kirk's Tooth Gap's avatar

Switching topics to Matas for a minute... I think it's too soon to say Matas isn't going to work out with Caleb, but if it does become clear that they just don't work together, is there a world where the Bulls move Caleb to SF?

I kind of feel like Caleb at SF and Miller at PF would be a good combo. Miller doesn't need the ball in his hands to be useful on offense, unlike Matas. He's also a really good rebounder, which is an area we know Caleb hasn't been amazing at so far. Miller will also be cheaper than Matas on their next contracts which would afford the Bulls some flexibility at other positions.

I really like MikeDC's suggestion of trading Matas to Philly for Edgecombe. Edgecombe is definitely the better player but doesn't fit as well in their win now plans. Could a deal where Chicago sends Matas and Smith (two guys who fit areas of need for Philly) and some second rounders in exchange for Edgecombe and maybe a minimum guy like Edwards entice Philly or am I just dreaming? I assume Philly wouldn't be interested with how their season has started, but maybe they start having some doubts if LeBron and Embiid miss significant time and they start losing.

Thomas's avatar

If the 6ers front office has object permanence, I don't think they'll panic trade to cover injuries in the regular season. Either Lebron and Embiid play in the playoffs and they're a contender, or they don't and they're not.

your friendly BullsBlogger's avatar

it doesn't make sense for Philly - a win-now title contender - to trade for an unproven player.

I don't think Graham is going to move Buzelis until at least a full year of on-court evidence of him playing with Wilson. But say he does, the target in a trade return will either be a rookie contract player who shows promise but a bad positional fit (like Buzelis here) or picks

TheMoon's avatar

I think it makes more sense to keep Giddey in the starting lineup and swap Jones and Matas. The starters lack ballhandling. Swapping Jones for Giddey doesn't fix that.

Charrua's avatar

It's still early (although Giddey looked bad in preseason too), but what I see is a guy who may be either in terrible shape or has decided to mimic the Reinsdorfs and stop caring about basketball.

It's not just that Powell isn't as complementary as Coby. His rebounding is the worst of his career, as his steal rates and his block rates. He's taking the least amount of shots of his career and is somehow posting his worst TS% too.

If this keeps happening, it's gonna be impossible to move him without giving up picks.

I prefer shutting him down to benching him, frankly. The bench isn't gonna fix whatever is wrong with him.

Thomas's avatar

Giddey is not a good basketball player. He has one above average skill (creative passes) and he's below average at everything else. Yes we AK blew his one remaining asset (Caruso) for a bad player. We need to move on ASAP

H_Vaughn's avatar

He looks like a giraffe walking in wet cement bringing the ball up court. Atrocious defender, like 32nd percentile. Park him next to Williams (or better yet, waive and stretch Williams and use the roster spot to pan for gold).

Thomas's avatar

I also think being a lefty, guys aren't used to guarding that night in and night out which makes him look better than he is until the games matter and defenders are locked in on individual tendencies. I know it's small sample size but we've seen this in play in games

Captain Kirk's Tooth Gap's avatar

Wait, are we not talking about Giddey anymore? He's not a lefty.

Thomas's avatar

He's left handed when dribbling

THEKILLERWHALE's avatar

Just an all time bad trade. They have more 1st one picks than they can use. Every contender in the league would have killed to add him as he is a purely complementary player with a few very important, elite skills. And we get nothing for him in a seller's market.

Piccolomair's avatar

It's not even creative passes. It's not like he delivers pin point bounce passes to cutters or finds lobs, or a no look dime to the opposite corner or fakes one pass and throws another. It's just "guy is open at the elbow - PASS!!" the Fanciest pass he has is an overhead skip pass.

He just is a prolific passer and apparently all the passing statistics love him for that

your friendly BullsBlogger's avatar

addressing several comments here:

I think a 'shutdown' attempts to address priorities that are less important. I don't care about Giddey's career development, so if he can't get better off the bench then so be it. And I don't care about his trade value. He didn't have positive trade value before the season. It's technically a worse position for the team if he has an even more-negative value contract (the result of Patrick Williams's change from stagnation to regression) now, but it doesn't change the simple status of him being functionally untradeable

And so what is important - good developmental lineups for Caleb Wilson and staying competitive in games - means Giddey can come off the bench. As Moon said, the lineups need more ballhandling (I agree, just think starting Matas is more important) so they would really be in deep shit if no backup PG. And heck we have no reason to think a benching wouldn't 'wake up' Giddey. He's likely plateaued as a bench player anyway, just a starter on bad teams (until now).

Gorditadogg's avatar

I thought the Bulls were going to have a new defensive identity this year. When is that supposed to start? You can't allow layup parades like we've been doing and expect to be competitive. We are the easiest team to score against at the rim. We are 5th in the league at fouling, yet in the bottom half at creating turnovers, and in getting defensive boards.

Just awful defense so far. We have a lot of young, quick, long athletic players on the team, I think a good coach should be able to get them organized enough that we could put up some resistance.

H_Vaughn's avatar

They don't look to be playing a defensive system at all. Just straight man-to-man. Minimal rotation, no blocking out. Just getting belt to ass by more talented players every trip down the court.

MikeDC's avatar

"Patsy" is an identity.

Piccolomair's avatar

I'm late to the party but wanted to share a site I just found that has some awesome insights and a cool interface for analyzing players

https://readthegame.com/