Blog a Bull: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Georgia 26, Tennessee 14: A Vol Fan Reacts Bar-right-arrows



My Man Sam(tm) isn't reading

I'm a day late on this one too (the Bulls blogosphere is getting intense!), but Sam Smith took some cheap shots at pantsless masses in this week's 'ask Sam':

I don't read any blogs. I find it interesting the way the national political campaigns (my first love and job) have hired people to interact with the blogosphere. You may say I'm old, out of touch and cranky, and I probably would have to agree. I'm also probably resentful on some level as I see this unsubstantiated, personal opinion passing for journalism and weep for America and the world. People do seem to read this stuff and equate it with what we do at The Tribune or other media and don't make much distinction.

How is it I can work for decades developing contacts around the NBA and traveling regularly around the NBA and talking with the decision makers and some guy in his basement in his underwear is writing something that has credibility? As close as I can figure, these bloggers are the electronic version of the neighborhood tavern. You used to go in and hear people wailing about sports or politics and offering opinions on all the major issues. We did our man in the street interviews when such issues came up. Now, these people we used to ask for opinion started these blogs and are supposed to be experts. How can that be? I never see any of them, I never hear the coaches and general managers and players I talk to saying they talked to them. So where do they get their information?

People often doubt the traditional media, but we are out asking questions, developing sources of information and interacting with the participants. What are these bloggers doing? I'm fortunate on some level to be getting close to retirement because if these blogs are credible sources of information, there's no point in spending all the time on the road that I do. And did you see that kid eating his ice cream and putting his hands on everything and can't someone shut that baby up and whose idea is it to give these kids a snow day and when I was their age I used to walk 15 miles to school in the snow. And without shoes!

So Sam's a little self-aware of his crankiness, which is reassuring. Besides, that's one of his endearing qualities as a writer. But his real problem is displacing his animosity towards bloggers that seemingly should go toward stupid people who can't tell the difference between actual journalism and what usually goes on with blogs.

(Of course by spelling this out I'm implying that you all are stupid as well, but, anyway: Blogging is just a tool. And while many bloggers can be considered tools themselves (heh), it's up to the reading audience to discern the credibility (or even readability) according to the content, not how it's conveyed.)

But what set this rant apart was his analogy between blogs and the neighborhood tavern. That's exactly how I envision what this place is like...just a place to talk Bulls. Plus the benefit over who you'd find at actual neighborhood taverns (not even considering the out-of-chicagoans) is that the people here know and enjoy their Bulls basketball. (And I get to hold court, which can only happen at a real tavern on karaoke night.) But this place is not meant to be any type of reporting or source-gathering. I will say Sam himself speculates trades out of thin air like any blogger could, but beyond that nobody's trying to take his job. There are sports bloggers out there who are trying to be real journalists through their blogs, and more power to them. But I prefer the tavern analogy much more.

Anyway, it's too bad that Sam can't seperate the medium from the message, as he really could make a good blogger. In a previous 'Ask Sam' he lamented the lack of coverage the NBA was getting in the midst of Bears-mania...and he could've been pumping out blog posts that whole time. One of his contemporaries, Dave D'Allesandro, has a good blog to model his own after. Hell, he picks up an extra paycheck on the side just like Sam! Sam he likes to write and interact with his readers...seems natural to me. And if he happens to ever stop by here, even if it turned out he was mostly ignored (like an odd old man should be at a bar), he'd still be welcome.

0 recs | Comment 14 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I've read Sam for
years.  Sam reports old information you find on Hoopshype and confabulates trades which gets into Hoopshype.  There is often more reliable thoughts and trade possibilities on this blog than I find in Sam's column.  I enjoy the this blog much more than anything Sam has written in a long time.
chgobr

by chgobr on Feb 15, 2007 7:03 PM CST   0 recs

well put matt
I've often wonderded why I spend so much time here, knwoing that I'm not going to find any true hints or rumours, and pretty mcuh just discussing my beloved bulls. Then I realized it was just that - the love of talking about my boys (yes i said it paxjax...i feel like the 16th guy on the bench). Anyone who takes what matt does, any other blogger does, or us creten commentators do to have fun serisouly needs to get things checked out

by milesgmsu on Feb 15, 2007 7:13 PM CST   0 recs

It is not just the facts
that are important.  I love the Bs and because of some emotional defect, I find my mood effected by how they are doing.  It is just plain fun to find others to share my joy or misery.  Sam doesn't seem to care.  The fiction he writes seems almost provocative to get his ideas into other venues.  I don't think he even uses any sources in his fiction.
chgobr

by chgobr on Feb 15, 2007 7:22 PM CST   0 recs

There's plenty of actual news here
We do have Kevin, after all.

by Big D on Feb 15, 2007 7:23 PM CST   0 recs

Hahahahaha
Bahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha (gasp) hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
"all the girls loved BJ." -sue369

by Colossus on Feb 15, 2007 7:29 PM CST to parent up   0 recs

Unfortunate generalization
Sam speaks about the "neighborhood tavern" like its a bad thing!  I typically like Sam - I wish Eddy Curry was still around so we could read about the many ways Sam tries to trade him - but he's off on this one.

Not to be a sycophant, but I agree with Matt's assessment.  There are many blogs out there that are the Internet version of Jerry "Crumbs" Krause:  Slovenly shut-ins that crave the "Sleuth's" reputation of knowing things that no one else does.  IMHO, Sam is right to ignore those for his stated reasons, but he's putting all blogs in that group.  "Blog a Bull" is not one of those blogs.

I visit blogs like this one for a number a reasons:

  • One-stop shopping for Bulls news (Sam gives no credit for sites like this linking to online news from the local papers)
  • Entertaining and informative conjecture on the team
  • Reaction and opinion regarding the news that is reported in the "official" media
  • Modern statistical analysis I can't get in the Trib or from chicagosports.com
  • That unique perspective of the "objective homer"; I really like the team, but I like to see them called out for their blunders
  • If I went to the neighborhood tavern daily for a break at work, I probably wouldn't keep my job.
So keep up the good work.  Don't let Sam I Am get you down.
Wrecked 'em? Damn near killed 'em!

by mdmnd9294 on Feb 16, 2007 8:01 AM CST   0 recs

If I had more time...
It would be really interesting to go back to last year's Sam articles to see what he was proposing.  I know Deng was his go-to trade bait last year.  If I recall correctly, he was always talking about what we could get with Deng.  I just don't remember what any of his ideas were.

I'm sure Gasol was not one of them.  

Anybody remember?

The red and white

by Scott 9 on Feb 16, 2007 9:49 AM CST   0 recs

I remember
a lot of KG from last year. In here any way. I think Sam was pushing that too.
Thabo....the accent is sweet!!

by sue369 on Feb 16, 2007 9:55 AM CST to parent up   0 recs

hey this
has nothing really to do with the bulls, but has more to do with the city of chicago. I noticed on the blogabull website that there was an advertisement for barack obama. I was wondering whether this was simply an advertisent or an endorsement by this site.
And in either case what everyone feels about it.  
(i must admit, I'm not sure how this site raises revenue or how it decides its advertisers, I'm interested in the response)
thanks

by NocChapu on Feb 17, 2007 12:49 AM CST   0 recs

Considering that
right over it is the word "Sponsors" in big, white letters, seems kinda obvious.

What do I feel about it?  I feel that OBAMA FUCKING RULES.

"all the girls loved BJ." -sue369

by Colossus on Feb 17, 2007 10:23 AM CST to parent up   0 recs

Hatfields vs McCoys
I think it's important to remember the environment in which Matt's Man Sam(tm) is placed.  He works at a newspaper and is surrounded by other journalists.  As Matt mentioned, I think he's a lot more self deprecating and self-aware than most journalists, especially those that cover sports.

However, I believe that journalists in general are terrified of blogs.  They are constantly trying to defend their turf.  They have been professionally trained and don't want to cede any credit to "amateurs" who are contributing their writing to the world free of charge.  As I've mentioned here a couple of times, I'm a huge Michigan football fan (not trying to rile you up, miles, just bear with me).  Early in the season, announcers were constantly saying that "the bloggers want Lloyd Carr to be fired."  This was, if not patently untrue, extremely misleading.  While there may have been a blog or two out there calling for the man's head, the vast majority of them were staunch defenders of Carr.  The people who wanted him canned were, for the most part, the casual fans who don't really understand the team that well or follow things that closely.  Yet, in broadcast after broadcast, all the way through the Rose Bowl, people like Brent Musburger continued to say, "early in the season, the bloggers wanted Carr gone."  I raise this issue because it speaks to the fact that most "real journalists" don't read any of the blogs they vilify.  In fact, Sam says here that he doesn't read any blogs.

Back to my main point, Sam is surrounded by other journalists who are, perhaps rightfully, fearing that their business is being eroded by blogs.  So in his world, blogs are getting a terrible rap, and he's going to hear about the worst kind of "reporting."  Even if that's not ever happening.  Networks and newspapers often believe that it is in their best interest to defame blogs.  Perhaps that is true, perhaps that is not, but the perception is there.  I think Sam would probably enjoy checking out this particular forum as it seems most of us are fans of his.  But the overarching thing is, blogs are here to stay and will continue to grow in popularity as long as there are talented people putting their effort into them.  The picture Sam paints of the "blogger" is propaganda, not generated by Sam, but certainly repeated by him.  But then someone stumbles cross BlogABull and realizes that there's a ton of quality stuff in here...

by corey williams corey benjamin on Feb 17, 2007 11:07 AM CST   0 recs

I'm hoping
Sam posts something here.  Maybe a sneak preview to the Monday column.  
chgobr

by chgobr on Feb 17, 2007 12:43 PM CST to parent up   0 recs

chris/kevin...
can you call your connections and tell us

by milesgmsu on Feb 17, 2007 3:56 PM CST to parent up   0 recs

The irony ...
is that I always assumed Sam Smith was the guy making up stuff while sitting around in his underwear.  I've never read a column I thought he actually did reporting on.  

by ericthebull on Feb 19, 2007 8:36 PM CST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Chicago Bulls.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Maya_small
Some thoughts on Noah
Maya_small
Gordon finally signed, let's talk about Deng
Small
Rumor Press Update on Gordon
A_bj_small
Gordon's decision made - just not known [UPDATE (?)]

Recent FanPosts

Small
Grow your beard and get to the rack
Bolo_picture_small
Kurt?
Small
Blog a Bull - Put Up or Shut Up - NBA Predictions (w/poll)
Small
Does anyone know
Blogabull_s_small
Two season previews
Derrickrosebulls_small
Whats the missing piece?
Small
Change of pace, anyone?
Small
Derrick Rose?
Chapu_small
Another strange illness for Eddy Curry

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Blogabull_s_small your friendly BullsBlogger

ad

Site Meter